Transformation Tool Contest (TTC) 2016

Solutions to the Class Responsibility Assignment Case

Case resources:

Description and case resources (Github repository)
Case presentation
Discussion of solutions and open peer reviews (Github issue tracker)
Evaluation sheet (as provided by case authors)
Evaluation form (Google form)
Evaluation sheets results
Post-proceedings in CEUR-WS.org
Correction: the authors for "Solving the Class Responsibility Assignment Case with UML-RSDS" are Kevin Lano, Shekoufeh Kolahdouz-Rahimi, and Sobhan Yassipour-Tehrani.

The following 9 solutions were submitted:

Tool	Authors	Artefacts	Opponents
NMF	Georg Hinkel	PDF Description SHARE Demo SCM	András Szabolcs Nagy et al. Kristopher Born et al.
VIATRA	András Szabolcs Nagy et al.	PDF Description SHARE Demo SCM	Leif Arne Johnsen et al. Kristopher Born et al.
UML-RSDS	Kevin Lano et al.	PDF Description SHARE Demo SCM	András Szabolcs Nagy et al. Filip Krikava
ATL/Java	Leif Arne Johnsen et al.	PDF Description SHARE Demo SCM	Christoph Eickhoff et al. Filip Krikava
Excel	Maximiliano Vela et al.	PDF Description SHARE Demo SCM	Kevin Lano et al. Alexandru Burdusel et al.
SDMLib	Christoph Eickhoff et al.	PDF Description SHARE Demo SCM	Georg Hinkel Maximiliano Vela et al.
MDEOptimiser	Alexandru Burdusel et al.	PDF Description SHARE Demo SCM	Leif Arne Johnsen et al. Christoph Eickhoff et al.
Henshin	Kristopher Born et al.	PDF Description SHARE Demo SCM	Kevin Lano et al. Maximiliano Vela et al.
SIGMA	Filip Krikava	PDF Description SHARE Demo SCM	Georg Hinkel Alexandru Burdusel et al.

Awards

The solutions were scored at the contest, resulting in the following awards:

The best overall solution was based on the rating from the peer-review phase as well as the performance and quality.

The Best Overall Solution: VIATRA

2nd Best Overall Solution: Henshin

3rd Best Overall Solution: SIGMA

The best quality solution was based on the rating by the participants during the TTC'16 workshop day on 8.7.2016.
The results are available in this pivot table

The Best Quality Solution: Henshin

2nd Best Quality Solution: VIATRA

3rd Best Quality Solution: SIGMA

The best performance solution was based on the generated CRA-Index.

The Best Performance Solution: VIATRA

2nd Best Performance Solution: Henshin

3rd Best Performance Solution: SDMLib

The most interesting solution was a special price for a solution that was entirely done in Excel producing good CRA-Index as well as excellent execution times.